Keep up with the latest hiring trends!

6 Things Top Performing Recruiters Do That You Don’t: Part 1

An A plus is given to a student for great work being achieved.

Over the last number of months, we’ve been a little busy here at Social Talent HQ. We’re in the process of building a new analytics tool that will allow recruiters and their managers to track their performance and productivity day-by-day. We’re crazy excited about it and cannot wait for you guys to see the finished product.

In building that tool, we’ve been granted access by a number of customers to a lot of data concerning how recruiters use the web on a day-to-day basis. 3000 recruiters to be exact. And we were also given 6 months special access to the overall performance reports of those recruiters by the managers of about 1000 of those 3000 recruiters. As a result, we’ve been granted the unique opportunity to granularly analyse a large number of recruiters web behaviour over time and extrapolate how that behaviour correlates with high, average and low-performing recruiters.

We’ve been able to see:

  • how many sites they visit on a daily basis
  • which websites they visit on a daily basis
  • how they use each of those websites
  • what order they use those websites in
  • what quantity they use those websites in

And in being able to see all these things, we’ve been able to notice a number of patterns that distinguish high-performing recruiters from low performing recruiters that you may find interesting. More importantly, we were able to see what smart, high-performing recruiters do day-to-day on the web and how differently they use it compared to average and low-performing recruiters.

This is what we found:

1. High performing recruiters spend less time online

The first thing we analysed when it came to recruiters’ web usage was the number of web pages recruiters visited on a daily basis. It turns out that web usage varies massively between low and high performing recruiters. Low-performing recruiters spent 50% more time online than top performing recruiters:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.32.27

That’s not to say those low performers were using the web for anything other than work, that 50% more relates to time spent online on day-to-day sourcing and recruiting activities. But how can someone be a lower performer even though they spend more time on the internet sourcing?

After digging down into the data, we found that although high and medium performing recruiters were spending less time on the internet, they were using it more efficiently than low performing recruiters. In other words, the results the high performers got in less time, were higher and with less effort – a key difference when it comes to productivity.

How are they using the internet in that case? We’ll answer that question over the next four points, starting with LinkedIn usage.

2. High performing recruiters use LinkedIn less

According the results of our research, recruiters spend a whopping 46% of their online web usage time on LinkedIn. That’s approximately 7 times more time than all job boards combined, 4 times more time than all other social networks combined and almost twice as much time as time as they spend elsewhere on the net. That’s A LOT of time!

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.40.56

Now, let me draw your attention to another study conducted by Silk Road. In their latest 2015 Source of Hire survey, Silk Road found that direct sourcing (what recruiters use LinkedIn for the most) accounts for approximately 10% of all hires a recruiter will make. On the contrary, job boards/CV databases (aka those things most recruiters spend 7 times less time using) account for 16% of all hires a recruiter makes. Meaning the return on investment of LinkedIn is much lower than job boards:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.38.06

When you calculate the difference between the two percentages (10% and 16%), job boards/CV databases account for 60% more hires than LinkedIn. So while most recruiters don’t fill the majority of their jobs through LinkedIn, they continue to spend the vast majority of their time on it and not on other more productive sources.

With that in mind, does it then surprise you to hear that, based on our research, that low-performing recruiters spend 60% more time on LinkedIn than high performers? No, I’m sure it doesn’t! Our research found that low performers have quite a large disproportionate usage of LinkedIn compared to average and high performing recruiters:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.32.49

This doesn’t mean LinkedIn is a bad tool, far from it. It just means that those low performing recruiters aren’t using LinkedIn as fast and as efficiently as high performers. How are high performers using LinkedIn? Stay tuned.

3. High performers spend less time searching for candidates

According to our research, high performers conduct 65% fewer searches per day:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.33.07
But “how can you perform better of you search less?!”, I hear you ask. Upon further inspection of the data and the performance reports we were privy to, we noted that low performers tended to start almost all of their LinkedIn searches within the top search bar on LinkedIn’s homepage:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.33.29

They start a search by typing in keywords like the skills or job title they’re looking to hire e.g. “java developer”, click search and are presented by the following result:

Screen Shot 2015-09-11 at 15.33.40

A million or so people all over the world who have a couple of those keywords somewhere on their LinkedIn profile. “Random!” I hear you shout! So what do they do next? Well, they look through an average of 3 of those search results pages, click through to approximately 3 of those profiles, then they start a new search from the same search box when they can’t find what they’re looking for… A time consuming strategy, but most definitely NOT a productive one!

So how are high-performing recruiters searching for candidates? The answer brings me to my next point. Which will be revealed in Part Two…

For now, download this FREE ebook packed with more stats and insights into what makes a super recruiter stand out from the crowd. Based on data from 2000 recruiters!

Read Part Two

Find out how the likes of IBM, IKEA and Siemens
drive hiring excellence with SocialTalent