Extended definition
A behaviorally anchored rating scale replaces vague labels with examples. On a typical scale, a high score means “good” and a low one means “below average,” which leaves every rater to decide what good looks like. On a BARS, each point is described by what a candidate at that level actually says or does, so raters compare evidence with the same written standard.
BARS were first developed for job performance appraisal by Smith and Kendall in 1963 and were later adapted for hiring. A research paper by Kell and colleagues at ETS calls them an essential component of structured interviews. They’re the anchored rubric behind a well-built interview scorecard.
For a question about handling a disagreement with a stakeholder, the anchors might read:
- Strong — Raised the issue early and directly, described the stakeholder’s position fairly, proposed options and explained how the disagreement was resolved and what they learned.
- Acceptable — Raised the issue and reached a resolution, but gave little detail about the other person’s view or their own reasoning.
- Weak — Avoided the disagreement, escalated straight away without trying to resolve it, or blamed the other person without saying what they did themselves.
How a behaviorally anchored rating scale is built
The classic method has five steps:
- Define the competencies — Start from a job analysis of what the role actually needs, such as stakeholder management or problem-solving.
- Collect critical incidents — Ask people who know the job well, known as subject matter experts, for real examples of strong and weak behavior.
- Retranslate — A second group of experts, separate from the first, sorts the examples back into competencies. Examples that don’t sort cleanly are dropped.
- Rate the examples — Experts rate how effective each remaining example is, and the ones they agree on become the anchors for each point on the scale.
- Attach anchors to questions — For interviews, each question gets its own anchors describing weak, acceptable and strong answers.
Many hiring teams use a lighter version. The US Office of Personnel Management’s structured interview guide has subject matter experts describe how employees at each proficiency level would answer each question. It then tells interviewers to use those examples as a general guide, not an absolute, when making their ratings.
Why a behaviorally anchored rating scale matters
Without anchors, two interviewers can hear the same answer and give different scores, because each is comparing it with a private picture of good. The OPM guide says the example behaviors provide a common framework for assessing candidates’ responses consistently. The Kell paper reports that using BARS to evaluate interviewees is associated with greater predictive validity and reliability, and with less bias.
Anchors also make calibration practical. When interviewers disagree, they can point to the anchor and discuss which description the answer matched, rather than debating impressions. That’s much of what makes a structured interview fairer than an informal one.
The trade-off is effort. The same paper notes that BARS are time-consuming and expensive to construct, so it’s worth starting with the questions that carry the most weight in the decision.
Common mistakes and misconceptions about behaviorally anchored rating scales
- Using adjectives as anchors — “Excellent communication” isn’t an anchor. Describe what the candidate said or did that makes it excellent.
- Anchoring only the ends — If only the top and bottom of the scale are described, raters guess at everything in between, which is where most answers land.
- Describing traits instead of behavior — “Confident” and “a natural leader” are impressions. Anchors should describe actions an observer could point to.
- Treating anchors as a checklist — Anchors are examples of a level, not phrases to listen for. A strong answer can look different from the example and still deserve the score.
- Never reviewing the anchors — Roles change. Revisit the anchors when interviewers keep disagreeing about the same question.
Train this skill: Browse the course library →
Frequently asked questions
What is a behaviorally anchored rating scale (BARS)?
It's a scoring scale where each level comes with a written example of the behavior that earns it. Interviewers and managers use it to rate answers or performance against shared descriptions instead of their own idea of what “good” means. In hiring, BARS are most often used to score answers in structured interviews, with separate anchors for each question.
What is an example of a behaviorally anchored rating scale?
For a question about handling a missed deadline, a strong anchor might read: “Flagged the risk early, agreed a new plan with stakeholders and explained what they changed afterward.” An acceptable anchor: “Delivered late but kept stakeholders informed.” A weak anchor: “Didn't flag the problem, or blamed others without describing their own actions.” Each score level gets its own description.
What is the difference between BARS and a graphic rating scale?
A graphic rating scale asks raters to mark a point on a scale labeled with general terms, such as “poor” to “excellent.” A BARS keeps the scale but attaches a description of specific behavior to each point. Graphic scales are quicker to build, but BARS give raters a shared standard, so their scores are easier to compare and explain.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of BARS?
The main advantage is consistency: raters compare answers with the same written examples, which makes scores easier to defend and discuss. BARS also describe strengths and gaps in concrete terms that are useful for feedback. The main disadvantage is effort, because good anchors take expert time to write and test, and they need updating when a role changes.
How do you use BARS in an interview?
Write anchors for each question before interviews start, covering at least weak, acceptable and strong answers. During the interview, take notes on what the candidate actually said. Afterward, compare those notes with the anchors, pick the closest level and record the evidence behind the score. Score independently before any debrief, so the anchors set the standard rather than the loudest voice.